The filming is downright primitive under Christy Cabanne’s non-interventionist helming in this Monogram Poverty Row production of Gene Stratton-Porter once popular novel. (Five filmings from 1924 to 1990.) But perhaps raw & obvious is the right way to go on this rural Pollyana tale of hard-luck kid Elnora Comstock (Marian Marsh) whose embittered, careworn mother (Louise Dresser) blames the child for the premature death of the father, drowned in the swamp on his way home for the birth. Largely raised by the kindly, childless neighbors over the years, and by two rich benefactors (a local dowager and a sparkling Eastern college boy) who take pity on the girl, she rises above schoolyard taunts and tattered homemade clothes to graduation honors and beyond, even finding peace with her mother. No surprises in how the story turns out, but plenty of surprises in Monogram putting together such a top-notch cast. Admittedly mostly stars on their way down, but Marsh had been starring with John Barrymore & Richard Barthelmess just a couple of years back; Dresser co-starring with Will Rogers in last year’s STATE FAIR. Ditto Henry B. Walthall earlier this year, in John Ford’s JUDGE PRIEST. While Ralph Morgan (brother of Frank) usually busy @ Fox. How’d Monogram ever afford them? (But worth it, the film apparently did a lot of business.) Currently available only in subfusc prints, but pretty interesting on many levels . . . other than moviemaking!
DOUBLE-BILL/LINK: To see Dresser really go to town on this sort of role, try THE GOOSE WOMAN/’25. https://maksquibs.blogspot.com/2009/08/goose-woman-1925.html























