Even in the ‘20s. ‘30s, and ‘40s, when B’way’s footprint on mass culture was at its height, reigning stage divinities rarely made the movie version of their latest smash.* Take Gertrude Lawrence, the hard-to-photograph stage star of this Samuel Raphealson play. Here, she’s been replaced by Claudette Colbert as an advertising man’s wife who succumbs to ‘the Five Year Itch’ when husband Ray Milland puts business first once-too-often and a flirtatious Brian Aherne pitches woo. Colbert proves one of the best substitutes in locating the elusive Lawrence charm, poise & presence.* (Previously, Colleen Moore, Norma Shearer, Joan Crawford & Ginger Rogers took turns; later Deborah Kerr.) Raphaelson’s rueful, but rather sour play is perilously ‘opened up’ by ‘Hollywood Ten’ scripter Allan Scott. (One of the few on the Communist Blacklist who actually tucked a bit of Leftist ideology in a film. Listen up in a subway sequence where bickering husband Milland & wife Colbert hear out various riders’ comments, including a proletariat type behind his newspaper. It’s Scott’s best addtion to the play. Elsewhere, he’s content to dumb things down with physical shtick and a kitchen cooking fiasco for Colbert.* Director Mark Sandrich shows a limber touch when he can (see prologue), but elsewise has to deal with the arguments on work, life and compatibility reduced to a level that makes Colbert’s final choice even more unsatisfying than I think Raphealson wanted it to be. Still, if not particularly funny, pretty interesting as a period piece on marriage & mores if you read between the lines.
SCREWY THOUGHT OF THE DAY: *Katharine Hepburn, an apparent exception to the substitution rule on her ‘comeback’ role in THE PHILADELPHIA STORY, only got the film because she controlled the show rights. *BTW note Kate also played the kitchen fiasco scene from this film for her PHILLY follow-up in WOMAN OF THE YEAR/’42.
DOUBLE-BILL/LINK: To see Colbert really run with the idea of fixing a stale marriage with a flirtation, Preston Sturges to the rescue in next year’s THE PALM BEACH STORY/’42. https://maksquibs.blogspot.com/2018/06/the-palm-beach-story-1942.html
ATTENTION MUST BE PAID: STAR/’68, the Julie Andrews/Robert Wise bio-pic on Lawrence famously missed capturing the aura that saw Noel Coward, Richard Rodgers, Cole Porter, George Gershwin and Kurt Weill all write SongBook Standards for a woman unable to stay on key.









