Always sad (though often informative) to watch a ‘Can’t Miss’ idea miss. Especially revealing, as here, when it misses thru unforced errors. The hard-to-screw-up setup is the largely true (?) story of an 1820s whaling voyage gone wrong and how it inspired Herman Melville’s MOBY DICK, published 1851.* Told in flashback as Melville scores an interview with crusty survivor Brendan Gleeson (shipped out at 14, he’d have been 45 at the time; oops!, Gleeson was and looks 60.). More serious problems start with art direction on a sea-faring town too quaint for words. (Were they anticipating the film adaptation of some imagined B’way musical version?) Then scuttling any chances before we even board The Essex by casting Benjamin Walker as ‘Nepo’ Captain Pollard and Chris Hemsworth as the disappointed, more experienced First Mate. Flavorless leads meant to suggest two sides of Captain Ahab, the actors shown up by most of the cast. Seen in support, Cillian Murphy could easily have bettered them playing both roles. Credit director Ron Howard for dropping his usual over-reliance on reaction shots to cue response, and for knowing how much CGI he can get away with at sea. But how could he, and the film’s many savvy Hollywood producers, not see (and fix) the film’s post mid-point doldrums in placing the Great White’s climatic wrecking of the whaling vessel at the one-hour mark? (Two return visits reek of narrative desperation.) And so easy to restructure since the story is being told in flashback. An easy bit of non-linear memory all that’s needed to solve a lot of problems.
WATCH THIS, NOT THAT/LINK: *Many MOBY DICK adaptations over the years, but (with the admittedly crucial exception of its unconvincing model whale) the 1956 John Huston/Gregory Peck assault looks better now than it did on release. https://maksquibs.blogspot.com/2016/01/moby-dick-1956.html









