As if doing penance for past pleasures, Carole Lombard (coming off the delicious melodrama of IN NAME ONLY/’39) and director George Stevens (fresh from Kipling’s tallest tale, GUNGA DIN/’39) went all high-minded on the noble (if underpaid/appreciated) profession of nursing as seen in A.J. Cronin’s novel. The popular Scotch novelist having something of a cinematic moment with VIGIL closely following THE CITADEL/’38 and this year’s THE STARS LOOK DOWN, both British-made prestige hits for M-G-M. This one opens with Lombard (more Goddessy beautiful than ever*) trying to stay awake all-night with her young diphtheria patient before turning duty over to kid sister Anne Shirley (looking like the young Lana Turner) who immediately drops the ball, then lets Lombard take the blame. Similar incidents pile up against a blameless Lombard as benefactors, bosses and big shots leave our good nurse holding the bag whenever things go wrong. And they go wrong a lot! Nonetheless, Carole perseveres, eventually proving her worth during a raging smallpox epidemic in a London isolation ward with the help of Brian Aherne, a devoted doctor who’s bothered to take note or what’s really going on behind the snubs and shifts in blame. Heck, even that deadbeat sister comes thru by the end. Dreary and self-sacrificial as this all is, the film builds sympathy, narrative interest and character as it goes along, but those two British-made adaptations have the edge on this one in almost every way.
DOUBLE-BILL/LINK: As mentioned, THE CITADEL and THE STARS LOOK DOWN. https://maksquibs.blogspot.com/2010/08/citadel-1938.html https://maksquibs.blogspot.com/2020/04/the-stars-look-down-1940.html
ATTENTION MUST BE PAID: *Plenty of big, stunning close-ups of Lombard at 32. Stevens and cinematographer Robert De Grasse obviously transfixed.









