One of those modest films where you know what you’re getting into before you get into it. A sure Audience Prize winner from some mid-list film fest; always a bad sign. A rueful domestic tale best-destined for The New Yorker as a piece of short fiction you never get to. An acclaimed ensemble cast that underwhelms. (Other than pater familias David Strathairn, always good; even better acting under his pseudonym, Sam Waterston.) Capturing the sympathies of many a super-hero hardened critic who take it under their wing like a charity case. (Only Angus MacLachlan’s third feature as writer/director since 2014.) Not that it’s bad. It’s adequate.* More’s the pity; a tasteless moment might hot things up. Strathairn’s the even-keeled Dad who runs a modest Heating-and-Cooling Factory & Service company with his son, a hail-fellow-well-met type who’s been papering-over serious personal issues (alcohol, drugs, infidelity, domestic violence) since returning from two military deployments. Happily, the daughter-in-law is a dream for Strathairn and his wife (a costumed tour-guide docent at a local historical ‘colonial’ campus). No doubt all the young couple needs is the baby they’ve long been trying for to get the relationship back on track. Instead, we get the other sister back to the homestead with her needy hot-button issues and difficult little girl, having once more left her no’count drug-brewing husband, to lech on the family teat and be a role model for bad parenting. MacLachlan’s careful to undersell this dramatic burgoo, only to juice things up in the last act with four or five big reveals. I didn’t buy into any of them, but tens of others felt differently.
READ ALL ABOUT IT : *I’ve stolen this idea of ‘adequate’ being worse than 'bad' from Orson Welles who said much the same in conversation with Peter Bogdanovich talking about Maurice Evans, the top Shakespearean during Welles’ Mercury Theatre heyday. WELLES: He took on practically everything in Shakespeare, the critics raved, and the people packed in to see him. BOGDANOVICH: And he was bad? WELLES: Worse - he was poor. Or so it’s transcribed (make that mis-transcribed) and printed in THIS IS ORSON WELLES. But on the original audio tapes Welles clearly says: Worse - he was adequate. FUN FACT: Evans, now probably best-known as Mia Farrow’s doctor in ROSEMARY’S BABY, was a ringer for Jack Benny! Undoubtedly one of the many reasons Ernst Lubitsch thought of Benny (of all people, radio comedian of genius Jack Benny!) to play that great, great Polish Shakespearean, Josef Tura.









