If you’re going to make yet another First Alien Contact movie (think THE DAY THE EARTH STOOD STILL/’51 & 08; CLOSE ENCOUNTERS/’77; ARRIVAL/’16; many more*), especially if you’re on a lowball Canadian budget, you better have imaginative filmmaking chops and a fresh concept. But the only fresh thing in writer/director Jonathan Sobol’s assault on the subject is Dennis Quaid’s face. Even that, less fresh than unnaturally refreshened. Quaid’s the billionaire visionary searching the heavens from his private island, built up to receive Alien Contact signals and staffed with space research geniuses leading the hunt. Borderline psycho David Thewlis; college wiz Isabelle Fuhrman; never laid Josh Hutcherson. The twist is that Thewlis crosses protocol and SENDS rather than only RECEIVES the coded calls and the beings respond in ways that scare the planet into a panic. Hours later, the island is invaded by overbearing military types who don’t understand the nuances of alien call-and-response etiquette. Will they take the whole operation down before friendly relations are established? Dull, dull, dull. And Sobol’s eccentric idea of even simple reaction shots less communicative than 'Gort' was in STOOD STILL.*
ATTENTION MUST BE PAID: *Sobol does have one stylistic quirk to watch out for. Though shot 1.85 : 1, he stages shots for a wider anamorphic frame with severe left/right positions that leave the middle empty. But since he places the conversations for two within a ‘flat’ frame ratio, the backs of some heads are out of frame.
WATCH THIS, NOT THAT: *Simpler & more effective (also really funny/really scary), less pretentious and far more emotionally affecting, Robert Wise’s ‘51 STOOD STILL still stands ahead of the pack.









