Now Over 5500 Reviews and (near) Daily Updates!

WELCOME! Use the search engines on this site (or your own off-site engine of choice) to gain easy access to the complete MAKSQUIBS Archive; more than 5500 posts and counting. (New posts added every day or so.)

You can check on all our titles by typing the Title, Director, Actor or 'Keyword' you're looking for in the Search Engine of your choice (include the phrase MAKSQUIBS) or just use the BLOGSPOT.com Search Box at the top left corner of the page.

Feel free to place comments directly on any of the film posts and to test your film knowledge with the CONTESTS scattered here & there. (Hey! No Googling allowed. They're pretty easy.)

Send E-mails to MAKSQUIBS@yahoo.com . (Let us know if the TRANSLATE WIDGET works!) Or use the Profile Page or Comments link for contact.

Thanks for stopping by.

Wednesday, November 3, 2021

GOOD SAM (1948)

After two gargantuan hits with GOING MY WAY/’44 and THE BELLS OF ST. MARY’S/’45, writer/director/producer Leo McCarey waited three years before returning to the screen only to discover he was through.  Just fifty-two at the time, he’d struggle to make four more films (two remakes; a Commie-Conspiracy embarrassment; a close-call social comedy) before calling it quits in ‘62.*  There’s something clueless in this discomforting moral parable about Gary Cooper’s pathological neighborly giving.  Unable to say no to anyone needing a helping hand, he discovers no good deed goes unpunished.  As written by McCarey, he’s more slow-witted sap than Good Samaritan, always putting wife Ann Sheridan & kids second to strangers in need.  An idea not without comic potential, but McCarey’s comic timing (always deliberate) is now a slow crawl of willful stupidity meant to be hilarious.  Perhaps with a slow-boil comedian like Edgar Kennedy (stellar for McCarey in DUCK SOUP/’33), but deadly inside this Father Knows Best setup.  About two-thirds of the way along, McCarey shows his hand and you can see he’s trying to ‘fix’ his friend Frank Capra’s IT'S A WONDERFUL LIFE, now a classic, but originally something of a disappointment two years before this.  And with McCarey’s collapsing technique (even at its best, something of an instinctual mystery), there's no solid craft to fall back on when the physical & relationship gags misfire.  At least, Coop looks better than he had recently, and Sheridan had a real gift for this kind of thing (see GEORGE WASHINGTON SLEPT HERE/’42).  But another fizzle when they both needed a career boost.  (Sheridan got her reprieve in I WAS A MALE WAR BRIDE/’49; Coop's delayed but spectacular in HIGH NOON/’52.)  And McCarey still showing a tin ear in choosing young secondary couples, here Joan Lorring & one-shot actor Dick Ross, both perplexingly bad.  One nice touch, a pregnant young woman big enough to actually be carrying a baby.  Unheard of at the time and the only forward looking thing in the movie.

SCREWY THOUGHT OF THE DAY: *A sharp decline paralleling two equally prominent right-leaning Hollywood Catholics more or less the same age, Frank Borzage & Frank Capra.  There’s a book in this.

WATCH THIS, NOT THAT: Before The Fall: usually rated lower than GOING MY WAY, McCarey preferred the sequel.  He’s right.  https://maksquibs.blogspot.com/2011/11/bells-of-st-marys-1945.html  After The Fall: https://maksquibs.blogspot.com/2019/12/my-son-john.html

No comments: