Award-slighted classic from the class of ‘39 (Oscar noms only for Score & Sound) easily tops the famous silent version which is crude by comparison. Helmer William Dieterle is at his best here, using remnants of German UFA expressionist style on Hugo’s cassoulet of history, cruelty & romantic debasement. The incredibly rich production & tech credits (how’d lil’ RKO pull it off?) never swamps the heartfelt perfs with Charles Laughton churning up chasms of self-loathing & sympathy (and what a voice he came up with!) while beauteous Maureen O’Hara & the remarkably young, nay, adorable Edmund O’Brien make real people of idealized types. The character casting, Thomas Mitchell, Walter Hampden, Harry Davenport & a shockingly malevolent Cedric Hardwicke, couldn’t have been bettered at Warners.
ATTENTION MUST BE PAID: The brief, but musically magnificent Hallelujah when Laughton’s Hunchback saves Esmeralda on the steps of Notre Dame, a contentious point of authorship between long time Hollywood composer Alfred Newman (who’s credited) and recent emigre Ernst Toch (who’s not). So good, it’s worth debating; so good, Newman reused it two more times. Which almost certainly means Toch wrote it.
No comments:
Post a Comment